Phonemic Awareness vs Phonics (And Why It Matters When Phonics Isn’t Working)
It was Friday spelling test, and Maya got 8 out of 10. A respectable score for a second grader. Her teacher recorded two errors and moved on. But if you looked at which words Maya got right and which she missed, a pattern emerged. The eight correct words were all high-frequency words the class had practiced all week: flashcards, rainbow writing, repeated exposure. Maya had memorized them visually. The two she missed were challenge words she had never seen before. She spelled “drum” as “jrm” and “slip” as “slap.”






